DATING & CRIME · REAL STORY

Sydney Loofe: the evidence behind the Audrey profile

The last message in the thread was an arrival notice. On November 15, 2017, Sydney Loofe's date said she was outside to pick her up. Years later, prosecutors showed those ordinary arrangements to a jury.

Sources: 10/11 NOW — Messages introduced at Trail's trial

Read the story ↓
The case at a glance

Key details

Sydney
24, living in Lincoln, Nebraska; she disappeared after a second date with someone using the name Audrey.
Outcome
Bailey Boswell received a life sentence for Sydney's murder in 2021.

Sources: Nebraska Supreme Court — State v. Boswell, 316 Neb. 542, S-21-980 · KMTV Web Staff — Sentencing coverage

Based on the dated reporting and records linked below.

The timeline

  1. November 15, 2017

    the second date. [1]

  2. November 8, 2021

    Boswell sentenced to life for murder, plus consecutive terms on two other convictions. [3]

  3. May 10, 2024

    Nebraska's Supreme Court affirmed her convictions and sentences. [3]

  4. April 20, 2026

    in Trail's separate proceedings, the U.S. Supreme Court denied his petition for review. That was not a new trial or a merits ruling. [5]

The conversations before the disappearance

Tinder records presented at trial showed messages beginning on November 11. Sydney and Boswell discussed food and possible outings before meeting on November 14. They arranged another meeting the following evening. The messages documented how contact became plans, and plans became a pickup time.

When Sydney missed work on November 16, the people who knew her noticed. Her manager described her as reliable and helpful. Her mother and friends were also unable to reach her. These were people responding to a break in Sydney's routine, not strangers interpreting a profile.

Sources: 10/11 NOW — Messages introduced at Trail's trial · Bayley Bischof, 10/11 NOW — Family, friends and investigators testify at Boswell's trial

A friend found the account

Friend Brooklyn McCrystal testified that she created a Tinder profile, matched with Audrey and obtained a phone number, which she gave to police. Investigators traced account records to Boswell. A witness also acknowledged a limit: the number alone could not establish who was operating the phone at a particular moment.

The wider investigation connected Boswell to Aubrey Trail and their Wilber apartment. Cell-site data helped reconstruct movements; Sydney's phone last contacted a tower at 8:32 p.m. on November 15. Later searches along a route identified through phone records recovered her remains.

Sources: Bayley Bischof, 10/11 NOW — Family, friends and investigators testify at Boswell's trial · Nebraska Supreme Court — State v. Boswell, 316 Neb. 542, S-21-980

What the records can tell us

The account, messages and location records answered different questions. Read together, they helped investigators reconstruct events. They do not establish that Sydney could have predicted the violence.

For practical context, read what a phone lookup can tell you and how to check a dating-profile photo. Consumer searches do not provide the investigative access described in this case.

Sources & reporting dates

  1. 10/11 NOW — Messages introduced at Trail's trial

    July 3, 2019

  2. Bayley Bischof, 10/11 NOW — Family, friends and investigators testify at Boswell's trial

    September 28, 2020

  3. Nebraska Supreme Court — State v. Boswell, 316 Neb. 542, S-21-980

    May 10, 2024

  4. KMTV Web Staff — Sentencing coverage

    November 8, 2021 hearing

  5. U.S. Supreme Court — Trail v. Nebraska, docket 25-6512

    April 20, 2026

Explore the checks

Learn what phone and photo searches can return, and how to interpret the findings.